A Clarksburg homeowner's master bathroom toilet kept running because the fill valve wasn't shutting off. They already had a replacement valve but couldn't loosen the mounting nut under the tank, so they asked us to install it.
The question
The toilet in the master bathroom kept running because the fill valve was not shutting off properly. The homeowner already had a replacement fill valve, but the mounting nut under the tank was too tight for them to remove.
What's going on
The fill valve is the part that refills the tank after a flush and shuts the water off when the tank is full. When it stops shutting off, water keeps running into the tank and out through the overflow tube. Replacing the fill valve is the usual fix. A fill valve is usually held to the bottom of the tank by a plastic locknut underneath. Over the years these nuts can get stuck from mineral buildup or from being overtightened.
What we recommended
- Asked: install a replacement fill valve the homeowner already had, because the mounting nut under the tank was too tight to take off.
- Quoted: labor only to remove the old fill valve and install the homeowner's new one, since they are supplying the part.
- We sent the labor estimate in writing and offered a visit date.
What the estimate covers
- Toilet fill valve (supplied by the homeowner)
The result
The homeowner has the labor estimate. The visit has not been scheduled yet.
Tips for Clarksburg homeowners
- A toilet that keeps running can waste a lot of water. Turn the shutoff valve behind the toilet clockwise (or a quarter turn on a lever-style valve) to stop it until the repair is done.
- Before replacing a fill valve, shut off the water, flush, and sponge out what is left in the tank. Have a towel and a small bucket under the tank for the supply line.
- Don't force a stuck plastic nut with a big wrench. Too much force can crack the tank, and a cracked tank usually means replacing the tank or the whole toilet.
- Tighten the new fill valve nut the way the valve's instructions say, usually snug by hand. Overtightening is one reason these nuts are hard to remove next time.
- Check the water level mark on the new valve or inside the tank, and set the float so the water stops below the top of the overflow tube.

